From "Reptiles of Fox Island 4/79" by T.J.McNitt, Bob Weber, (Lee Casebere) notes
TURTLES (Order Testudines)
| Common Name | Scientific Name | Family | Option | Comment |
| Snapping Turtle | Chelydra serpentina | tm, bw | ||
| Common Musk (Stinkpot) | Sternotherus ordoratus | Found 8/92 in Observation Center Yard | ||
| Eastern Box Turtle | Terrapene c. carolina | Two found in 8/92; One on lake road and one on Upper Dune Trail | ||
| Midland Painted Turtle | Chrysemys picta marginata | tm, bw | ||
| Blanding's Turtle | Emydoidea blandingii | bw | ||
| Eastern Spiny Softshell | Apalone s. spinifera | tm |
SNAKES (Order Squamata, Sub-order Serpentes)
| Common Name | Scientific Name | Family | Option | Comment |
| N. Banded Water Snake | Nerodia s. sipedon | tm | ||
| Midland Brown Snake | Storeria dekayi wrightorum | tm, bw | ||
| Eastern Garter Snake | Thamnophis s. sirtalis | tm, bw | ||
| Blue Racer | Coluber constictor foxii | tm, bw | ||
| Black Rat Snake | Elaphe obsoleta obsoleta | bw | ||
| Eastern Milk Snake | Lampropeltis t. triangulum | tm, bw | ||
| E. Massasauga | Sistrurus c. catenatus | tm, bw |